Sofia Falcone’s Origin Story in “The Penguin” Is Inspired by the Heartbreaking True Story of Rosemary Kennedy

The Penguin on HBO has got us all hooked, especially with how it’s flipping the script on some classic Batman characters. And if you thought you knew Gotham’s notorious crime families, think again.

One of the most intriguing characters to get a rework is Sofia Falcone, played by Cristin Milioti. She’s not just another mafia heir trying to take over Gotham—her story is much darker and more complicated than you might expect.

In the comics, Sofia’s family legacy is full of crime, betrayal, and tragedy, but the way The Penguin takes it all to the next level will have you second-guessing everything you thought you knew.

But there’s a heartbreaking twist to her story that’ll leave you stunned. It’s not just mob politics and gang wars, it’s a deep dive into betrayal, survival, and the consequences of messing with someone who’s been pushed too far.

Who is Sofia Falcone?

Cristin Milioti‘s Sofia Falcone, aka Sofia Gigante, is the daughter of Carmine “The Roman” Falcone, Gotham’s most infamous mob boss. But while her dad was the face of Gotham’s criminal empire, Sofia’s got her own plans for taking over.

She’s got ambition, ruthlessness, and the determination to rise to the top. In the comics, Sofia’s story starts in Batman: The Long Halloween and Batman: Dark Victory. She’s not afraid to get her hands dirty to climb up the criminal ladder, but it’s not all smooth sailing.

With her father’s empire crumbling after his fall, Sofia has to face off with everyone else trying to grab a piece of the Gotham pie, including rival mob bosses, corrupt cops, and costumed vigilantes.

Why is Sofia Falcone Called The Hangman?

Here’s where things get really dark. In the comics, Sofia Falcone becomes a serial killer known as The Hangman. Yeah, she doesn’t just play the crime game—she becomes a full-on villain.

The Hangman is a killer who targets police officers and murders them on holidays, leaving behind a creepy version of the Hangman word game, with letters missing from each victim’s body.

So, why does Sofia take on this twisted identity? It’s not just random violence—it’s a reflection of her psychological breakdown. In Batman: Dark Victory, after surviving a fall that everyone thought would be her death, Sofia returns with a thirst for revenge.

She takes out her anger on Gotham’s cops, killing them one by one and making sure they know it’s her. It’s a brutal, twisted version of justice, and it shows how far Sofia is willing to go to make Gotham fear her.

The Penguin show doesn’t follow Sofia’s story exactly as it’s told in the comics. Instead, the show flips it. In The Penguin, Sofia’s framed for being the Hangman, but the real killer is her father, Carmine.

It’s a subtle change, but it shifts Sofia’s role from being a straight-up murderer to a victim turned vengeful survivor. Her arc’s a total ride, and it’s easy to see why she’s one of the most fascinating villains in Gotham.

Sofia Falcone’s Comic Book Origins

If you’re a real Batman fan, you probably know that Sofia’s comic book origins are crucial to understanding her character. She first appeared in Batman: The Long Halloween, written by Jeph Loeb and illustrated by Tim Sale, which is basically one of the most iconic Batman runs ever.

In these comics, Sofia’s not just some side character—she’s part of a much larger crime saga involving her ruthless father, Carmine Falcone. What makes Sofia stand out is how she’s portrayed physically and emotionally.

In the comics, Sofia is massive—she’s drawn like a powerhouse, standing tall and intimidating. This makes her seem like a total beast in comparison to her fellow Gotham criminals, who tend to rely on brains or gadgets.

Is Sofia Falcone The Hangman in DC Comics?

So, yeah—Sofia Falcone is the Hangman in DC Comics, but it’s not as simple as it sounds. In Batman: Dark Victory, the sequel to The Long Halloween, Sofia’s officially revealed as the killer known as the Hangman.

After surviving what everyone thought was her death in the first book, Sofia comes back with a vengeance. Her father, Carmine, is dead, and Gotham’s crime world is in chaos. But instead of keeping things under control, Sofia goes off the rails, killing cops one by one in the same sick, twisted style her father set up.

The Hangman killings become a major plotline in Dark Victory, and it shows just how deep Sofia’s descent into madness goes. She doesn’t just pick up where her father left off—she surpasses him in terms of brutality.

The show The Penguin takes inspiration from this arc but gives Sofia a slightly different origin story. In the series, she’s framed for the Hangman murders, which leads to her being locked up in Arkham Asylum for years.

It’s only when she’s released that she begins to exact her revenge, slowly unraveling as a broken, vengeful character. In both versions, though, Sofia’s tragic story is a reminder of how power corrupts and destroys. Her rise and fall are as brutal as Gotham itself.

Sofia Falcone’s Origin Story was Inspired by Rosemary Kennedy

The Penguin creator Lauren LeFranc told EW that Sofia Falcone’s character was partly inspired by the tragic story of Rosemary Kennedy, the sister of former President John F. Kennedy.

If you don’t know the story, Rosemary was lobotomized when she was young because her family thought she was too “difficult.” Unfortunately, the lobotomy went horribly wrong, leaving her mentally and physically impaired for the rest of her life.

LeFranc saw this story as a perfect parallel to Sofia’s character arc. Just like Rosemary, Sofia’s family (mainly her father) saw her as a problem, someone who needed to be controlled.

The trauma that Sofia experienced shaped her into the ruthless character we see in The Penguin. That’s the heart of Sofia’s character—she’s not just a villain for the sake of being evil. She’s a product of abuse, mistreatment, and manipulation. And that makes her all the more dangerous.

Watch The Penguin on Max!