“The average shonenhead would explode from the experience”: ‘Re:Zero’s’ Reputation Is Attracting Fans for the Wrong Reasons

We’ve all had this experience where we start a certain anime due to a prior opinion that we have of it, but once we get into we realize just how wrong we were.

Re:Zero is one such anime that people pick up due to the base-level knowledge they have of it, but as they explore it they come to the realization that it is something entirely different from what it initially seemed like.

Re:Zero and its reality

Re:Zero − Starting Life in Another World follows the journey of Subaru Natsuki, an average Joe who gets transported to a fantastical realm, where he discovers that he commands an ability known as Return by Death. While the prospect of possessing power is exciting, the true nature of this power is haunting.

It is soon revealed to the viewers that Return by Death is an ability that forces one to relive past events after their death, meaning that even though they die, they are forced to carry the memories of their past life with them.

This is where the anime takes a turn as with each subsequent reset, Subaru is scarred emotionally and the series changes into a psychological tormentor that was only using the fantasy genre as a facade.

Re:Zero is not a Shonenhead’s cup of tea

Re:Zero being a psychological thriller that plays the facade of an action anime is one of the reasons why people, especially the ones that watch a lot of Shonen pick it up. While the initial setting and the surface-level knowledge might give them the impression that its an intense action anime, the subsequent story betrays such assumptions.

Rather than exciting the viewer with intense action, Re:Zero prefers to draw them in using its story and characters. The anime is like a slow burn, slowly increasing the mental scars on both its viewers and Subaru, and not giving enough payoffs. This causes the “shonenheads” to drop the anime mid-watch.

X user @ih8mylifeffs perfectly described this in his tweet:

>Try re zero thinking its a battle shonen

>Experience a psychological thriller

I wonder if the average shonenhead would explode from the experience

— Alex Graham Bell (@ih8mylifeffs) March 6, 2025

Another user @486SMT commented on how complex the anime and its characters are from an emotional perspective, and remarked that the shonenheads would panic by looking at it. The remark hints at how Shonen is sometimes all about epic fights.

they'll panic and self-destruct at the mere sight of emotional complexity

— Catsuki (@486SMT) March 6, 2025

And truth be told, Shonen anime is much straightforward when compared to Re:Zero, as it offers quick and straightforward victories. On the other hand, Re:Zero is visceral and each of Subaru’s deaths is a consequence of his action.

There is also the fact that Subaru, being a young protagonist, causes people to think of other younger protagonists, who come from Shonen anime, and this might also be a reason why they start watching Re:Zero. But unlike them, Subaru’s troubles and trauma have no end.

As the anime grows in popularity, and as it gets advertised more and more, people are bound to pick up the series under a number of speculations, most of which, will end up being false once they get deep enough into it.

Re:Zero is the kind of series that needs audience to look beyond the flashy powerups and lean into the story which is built on a profound understanding of psychology and until that is pushed through to the audience, it will only attract people for the wrong reasons.

The audience that comes in expecting a high-octane action rodeo, are instead offered a relentless, scarring journey that will surely make them “explode.”

Re:Zero is available to stream on Crunchyroll.