Why Do Singers Lip-Sync Instead of Performing Live During the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade?
- Singers lip-sync at the Macy’s Parade because live performances are too tricky.
- Stars like John Legend and Kelly Clarkson have explained why it’s necessary.
- The 2024 lineup included Idina Menzel, T-Pain, Jennifer Hudson, and more.
The Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade is one of the most magical events of the holiday season. From giant balloons floating through the streets of New York City to colorful floats carrying some of the biggest stars, it’s a tradition millions look forward to each year.
But here’s a little secret not everyone knows—most of the time, the performers aren’t actually singing live. Shocking, right? Instead of live vocals, most artists lip-sync to pre-recorded tracks while performing on their floats.
For some fans, this has been a surprising discovery, especially after moments like Rita Ora’s 2018 performance when a technical glitch made it obvious.
But before you judge, there are some good reasons behind this decision, and they’re not what you might think. Let’s break down why artists lip-sync, what some stars have said about it, and who’s taking the stage at the 2024 parade.
Why Don’t Singers Perform Live at the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade?
For years, nearly every singer at the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade has lip-synced instead of singing live. But it’s not because they don’t want to sing—it’s because live performances would be nearly impossible under these circumstances.
First, let’s talk about the floats. These incredible creations look beautiful on TV, but they’re not built to host live concerts. They’re constantly moving, making it tough to balance or even stand still. Plus, the sound systems on the floats simply can’t handle live vocals. Imagine trying to hit a high note while wobbling on a moving turkey float—it’s not exactly the perfect stage setup.
Then there’s the weather. New York City in late November is cold. Temperatures are often in the low 40s, and some years even colder. Freezing air doesn’t mix well with vocal cords, making it harder to sing live. John Legend, who performed in the parade a few years ago, explained the situation on social media.
The other reason? Live TV can be unpredictable. Technical glitches, weather problems, or even a sudden gust of wind could completely throw off a live performance. Lip-syncing ensures the performances go smoothly, so fans at home can enjoy the music without any awkward moments.
What Do Performers Say About Lip-Syncing at the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade?
Some artists have been open about lip-syncing at the parade, while others have clarified when their performances were actually live. In 2018, Rita Ora found herself at the center of a lip-syncing controversy when viewers noticed her vocals didn’t match her mouth during the parade.
Fans were quick to call it out, but John Legend came to her defense, explaining why all performers lip-sync (as mentioned above). To this, Ora replied, “It’s annoying for us but anyway! All my shows are 100 percent live always have been!” Check out the full post here:
Kelly Clarkson also addressed the topic that same year. She revealed that her performance with Brynn Cartelli was actually live despite the freezing weather. The American Idol alum proudly wrote on Instagram, per E! News:
Umm, I don’t know if y’all know this, but that was live! Brynn Cartelli, thank you — singing in this cold weather with me. It’s so cold in New York.
Over the years, some performers have chosen to break tradition and sing live, but for most, lip-syncing is the safest and easiest option.
Who’s Performing at the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade?
This year’s Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade had an incredible lineup of performers, delivering some truly show-stopping moments! Broadway superstar Idina Menzel performed on the Bronx Zoo’s Wondrous World of Wildlife float.
Meanwhile, Jennifer Hudson and Billy Porter took over Macy’s Herald Square with their powerful vocals. Other big names included Kylie Minogue, Lea Salonga, Rachel Platten, and even Jimmy Fallon & The Roots.
The parade also featured performances from Cynthia Erivo, Ariana Madix, and country duo Dan + Shay. With such a stacked lineup, this year’s parade was truly unforgettable.
