SUMMARY
  • 'How I Met Your Father' has been canceled, even though it won four Emmys.
  • The show struggled with ratings, despite critical acclaim and cool cameos.
  • The cancelation ended hopes for future 'How I Met Your Mother' spin-offs.

It’s a tale as old as time: a show that won hearts snagged awards and still got canceled. Meet How I Met Your Father, the spinoff of the cherished How I Met Your Mother.

The series, following Sophie and her Manhattan friends through the highs and lows of 30-something life, seemed set for success. With charm, a great cast, and enough Emmys to fill a trophy case, it had more than just a famous name. So why, oh why, is the show now a ghost of TV’s past?

How I Met Your Father
A still from How I Met Your Father (Credit: Hulu)

Despite a stack of Emmy Awards, Hulu has decided to bid a fond but final farewell to Sophie and her gang. Fans were clinging to hope, fingers crossed for a third season, but that dream has been dashed. For fans, this cancelation felt like the TV equivalent of a bad breakup.

An Emmy-Worthy Effort Fell Short for How I Met Your Father

A still from How I Met Your Father
A still from How I Met Your Father (Credit: Hulu)

Despite its impressive haul of four Emmy Awards, How I Met Your Father couldn’t escape the dreaded ‘cancelation’ label. The show was nominated seven times and won for categories like Outstanding Cinematography and Multi-Camera Picture Editing. 

These awards are no small feat and reflect the hard work of an incredibly talented crew and cast. The series had a lot going for it: a familiar universe, a charismatic lead in Hilary Duff, and plenty of nods to its predecessor.

SUGGESTED
“He’s such a stud”: How I Met Your Father Star Hilary Duff Wants Original Cast of How I Met Your Mother to Return After Neil Patrick Harris’ Legendary Cameo
“He’s such a stud”: How I Met Your Father Star Hilary Duff Wants Original Cast of How I Met Your Mother to Return After Neil Patrick Harris’ Legendary Cameo

Fans enjoyed the show’s new twist on a classic, but it couldn’t be saved from being canceled. The cancelation left everyone upset, especially since the show seemed ready to continue the legacy. Check out some fan reactions:

So, what exactly led to How I Met Your Father getting its final bow? It turns out that even Emmy wins aren’t always enough to save a show.

The Final Curtain Call: Why How I Met Your Father Didn’t Make the Cut

A still from How I Met Your Father
A still from How I Met Your Father (Credit: Hulu)

Ratings play a huge role in any show’s fate. If critics have mixed reactions to it, networks might decide it’s time to move on. This is why, despite its best efforts, How I Met Your Father struggled to keep the audience as hooked as its predecessor.

SUGGESTED
“I’ve made it in show business”: One Scene in ‘How I Met Your Mother’ That Marked a Huge Milestone For Ted and Robin Also Gave Josh Radnor a Much-needed Confirmation
“I’ve made it in show business”: One Scene in ‘How I Met Your Mother’ That Marked a Huge Milestone For Ted and Robin Also Gave Josh Radnor a Much-needed Confirmation

The show battled tough competition in the crowded streaming world. Hulu’s choice to cancel after only two seasons, despite good reviews and loyal fans, was a hard call. Even executive producer Craig Thomas shared his disappointment, looking back with a hint of nostalgia. He shared on Facebook (via TVLine) in 2023:

Thanks to the wonderful cast and crew who worked so hard on #HIMYF, sometimes this is how it goes in this crazy business. I will miss the feeling, even from afar, of a bunch of #HIMYM production all-stars continuing to make stuff together which always made my heart feel full!

The failure of How I Met Your Dad years earlier didn’t help either. It seems the universe might have been out of spin-off luck.

How I Met Your Father is available to watch on both Hulu and Disney+.

Explore from around the WEB