Skip to content
Hollywood Movie News

“How is this a movie”: Jack Black’s ‘A Minecraft Movie’ Seemingly Using a Dark Joke as a Plot Point Creates Mixed Feelings

“How is this a movie”: Jack Black’s ‘A Minecraft Movie’ Seemingly Using a Dark Joke as a Plot Point Creates Mixed Feelings
Share
Share

A second trailer of Jack Black’s A Minecraft Movie has hit the internet. While the reactions to this are better than the last one, they are not entirely positive. There could be many reasons why fans are reacting this way to the whole ordeal including the skepticism that was always going to be there because the video game has so many lovers worldwide.

Jack Black in a still from A Minecraft Movie
Jack Black in a still from A Minecraft Movie | Source: Warner Bros. Pictures

A particularly dark joke related to the game being used in the new trailer of the movie has drawn mixed reactions from people, and it does not look all that good. This is not to say that everyone hates it, but some people have also pointed out that it is actually quite disturbing.

Jack Black’s A Minecraft Movie‘s Second Trailer Has Apparently Used This Joke as a Plot Device

A still from A Minecraft Movie
A still from A Minecraft Movie | Source: Warner Bros. Pictures

Minecraft has been undoubtedly one of the most beloved video games since the early 2010s. Created by Mojang Studios, it is a sandbox game that has become extremely popular over the years, thanks to the yearly Minecon conventions, merchandise, parodies, and social media marketing.

It took Mojang Studios over a decade to get an adaptation of the game off the ground. It began with plans to make a series, but the idea soon evolved into a film adaptation instead. Now, a live-action film is all set for release next year. Besides Jack Black in the role of Steve, it will also feature actors like Jason Momoa and Jennifer Coolidge.

The second trailer was released by Warner Bros. Pictures and seemingly features a variation of the dark joke, “The children yearn for the mines” which is a catchphrase used for the video game that satirically supports the loosening of child labor laws. The reactions to this have been mixed. Here is what some of them had to say:

https://twitter.com/SpIinterCal/status/1858973372862132531

A Redditor also expressed their discomfort over the use of this catchphrase in a now-deleted post. That said, how the movie will actually end up performing remains to be seen. In the meantime, the director and producer for the movie have stated that they were unsurprised by the reactions the trailer elicited.

A Minecraft Movie Director and Producer Were Not Very Suprised by the Underwhelming Reaction to the First Trailer

A still from A Minecraft Movie
A still from A Minecraft Movie | Source: Warner Bros. Pictures

This is not the first time that a video game has been adapted for the big screen. The film adaptation of Super Marios Bros. and the TV show adaptation of The Last of Us are proof enough of the fact that video game adaptations can be successful too.

A Minecraft Movie, on the other hand, has attracted quite a bit of negativity so early on. Luckily, director Jared Hess and producer and Minecraft senior director of original content, Torfi Frans Olafsson are not very surprised by this. Hess recently told IGN:

I mean, look, we knew this game represents so many different things to so many different people. We knew that whatever we led out with, there was going to be strong opinions across the spectrum of what people were expecting, what they wanted it to be. Everybody brings their own special personal connection to the game. So we were ready for everything.

Olaffson also addressed that they had anticipated criticism over the fact that the film is live-action instead of animated. He said that the filmmakers wanted to do something different from what has been done before and there is a lot of animated stuff already out there, so it felt right to go the live-action route for this one.

A Minecraft Movie | Official Trailer

A Minecraft Movie is scheduled to be released on April 4, 2025.

Frequently asked questions

Why did the second ‘A Minecraft Movie’ trailer cause mixed reactions among fans?

The trailer reworked a well-known dark Minecraft internet meme that jokingly references mines and child labor into a spoken line for Jack Black’s character, Steve, who quips that as a child he yearned for the mines. Reactions split between fans who enjoyed the cheeky callback and others who found the joke off-putting, with some online commenters questioning the film’s overall tone.

Who stars in ‘A Minecraft Movie’ and who directed it?

Jack Black stars as Steve, alongside Jason Momoa and Jennifer Coolidge. The film was directed by Jared Hess, with Torfi Frans Olafsson, Minecraft’s senior director of original content, among its producers.

When was ‘A Minecraft Movie’ released and what kind of adaptation is it?

A Minecraft Movie was released theatrically on April 4, 2025. It is a live-action adaptation of the globally popular Minecraft video game, an approach the filmmakers chose to do something different rather than going the fully animated route.

Get the newsletter

Animation, anime, film & comics — the best of AnimatedTimes in your inbox.